The carbon brace
© Bernard et al.; licensee BioMed Central Ltd. 2013
Received: 1 June 2012
Accepted: 30 October 2012
Published: 14 February 2013
Skip to main content
© Bernard et al.; licensee BioMed Central Ltd. 2013
Received: 1 June 2012
Accepted: 30 October 2012
Published: 14 February 2013
The CMCR brace (Corset MonocoqueCarbone respectant la Respiration –which means Monoshell Carbon Brace respecting Breathing) is an innovative brace, used in orthopaedic treatment for progressive thoracic, thoraco-lumbar or combined scoliosis, whatever their etiology. It can be used at the very young age without disrupting the chest growth, but should be kept for reducible scoliosis in older teenagers.
The CMCR brace is monoshell while retaining the corrective principle of the polyvalve Lyon brace with one or two supports (brace “pads”) located on hump(s).In contrast to Lyon brace made of plexidur and structured by metal reinforcement with adjustable but fixed localized supports, the CMCR brace is made of polyethylene and carbon with adjustable and mobile supports. This mobility provides a permanent pressure, which varies depending on ribs and spine movements.
The correction is obtained without spinal extension so that each respiratory movement takes part in a gradual return to dorsal kyphosis.
Results were presented in two published analysis:
• In the first retrospective study about 115 patients, French-published in the Annals of Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation (2005), the CMCR brace stabilized moderate scoliosis, decreased the vital capacity (VC) of 13% compared to the VC without brace, and did not have sufficient impact on the hump reduction. Treatment had better results when started at Risser 3 or 4 than Risser 0, 1, 2. The brace was then modified to increase the dorsal pad pressure and the location of correction forces was defined more precisely through the use of 3D analysis.
• The second study published in Scoliosis (2011) mainly focused on the impact on VC at brace setting up and followed a cohort of 90 patients treated with CMCR. Girls as well as boys increased VC during treatment, and at brace definitive removal, VC had increased of 21% from the initial value, whereas the theoretical VC at the same time rose by 18%.
The difference between the time where the child actually wears its brace and the time asked by the clinician for the brace to be worn is only 1 hour, which means that this brace is accepted by teenagers.
Orthopaedic treatment is still a heavy treatment for teenagers in growth period. This orthosis is designed to partly maintain spine and chest mobility. We hope so to have part in improving life conditions of these teenagers, compared to those treated with rigid braces.
Idiopathic scoliosis affects 2 to 3% of the population, including 0.3 to 0.5% with a scoliosis over than 20°. The Lyon treatment is applied since the 1950s for the conservative treatment in scoliosis over 30° and comes in 2 phases:
Correction by 1 or 2 successive casts (Abbott plaster cast) made in EDF framework and worn 45 days each
Then adaptation of a Lyon brace, worn to bone maturity.
As we had to deal with earlier treatment of scoliosis, where clinical and radiological deformations are less expanded, we began to understand a bit more its evolution and were lead to develop corrective orthosis that suit to moderate scoliosis . Currently available braces have demonstrated a real efficiency but still present disadvantages because of their rigidity, especially for the thoracic function that is limited by the lack of expansion while breathing in.
The purpose of this paper is to present the CMCR brace (Corset Monocoque Carbone respectant la Respiration – which means Monoshell Carbon Brace respecting Breathing).
Scoliosis that present only a lumbar component will not be considered in the brace panoply of this work.
At the end of the 50’s, Pierre STAGNARA finalized his modernization and streamlining of Adolescent Idiopathic Scoliosis treatments, at Les Massues hospital. It was the time of « Lyon school » and the Lyon brace was born.
Scoliosis screening nowadays occurs earlier. Orthopaedic treatments by brace have to adapt to these lower angle deformations.
Braces should have minimal impact on these young children lives, while remaining effective on curves correction. Braces have to take into account new needs, such as comfort, lightness, aesthetic, preservation of respiratory capacity and overall respect for the child growth.
From the meeting of these new settings is born the CMCR. This monoshell brace was developed by Lecante society at the Centre des Massues  in Lyon in 1997, under the aegis of Dr. Bernard. Inspired by the location of the Lyon brace supports, the rigid pads are changed into mobile ones in the CMCR brace. It calls upon new materials, more efficient (x-rays transparent, dynamic…) but also more comfortable. Thus, results on scoliosis curves remain optimal without interfering with thoracic growth, and lie on a greater participation of the child, which is the key to the treatment success.
The CMCR is a light brace reinforced by carbon blades and implemented without prior casting.
The CMCR design is based on clinical and radiological data (Cobb angles, pelvic parameters, spinal 3D analysis): they allow us to give the right direction to the force(s) implemented in the brace to correct the scoliosis torsion. To this correction force will be opposed two counter forces, to obtain a 3-points effect. It is possible to use the extension component of the CMCR, offered by the monoshell structure of the brace, by adjusting the under-axillary supports.
In a recent work  we have been able to show the interest of this brace, through the appropriate use of carbon material, for the rib cage development and for the respiratory capacity of these children treated with CMCR during many years, at the time where the thoracic growth is the highest.
The CMCR originality lies in the appropriate use of prestressed carbon to create support forces on brace pad(s). This support keeps some mobility during movements, and especially in respiratory ones. Correction is thus permanent; the child cannot escape the support, as it is the case with rigid orthosis. The thorax mobility is preserved, sparing at best the subject breathing. Dorsal and lumbar pads can be adapted tailored to the desired correction, and considering the 3 plans. The brace will be individualized regarding curve type, subject age and weight, trying to get the best compromise for the patient, throughout treatment.
The CMCR is implemented at 12 years on average; a little younger in boys (11 years) than in girls (12 years).
It is generally worn for progressive scoliosis with a Cobb angle from 20 to 30°, but can be implemented in some other cases, taking into account the 3D analysis , patient age and sitting size, and curve(s) reducibility.
The CMCR is prescribed for combined scoliosis (or double major) in more than 73% of cases. Thoraco-lumbar scoliosis represents 15%, and finally 10% of thoracic ones.
This sharing out is not due to any technical specificity of the brace, but corresponds to the percentages of scoliosis various forms in our everyday practice. We need to state that no lumbar scoliosis is treated with CMCR, because we use another orthosis (3-points brace) for this kind of scoliosis.
Combined scoliosis: the brace is equipped with two mobile pads.
One pad on the dorsal deformity: after 3D analysis, the orientation of the support force corrects the torsion, with a maximal orientation ¾ antero-posterior when the torsion is maximal. Prestressed carbon of the mobile pad allows by its elasticity the inspiratory movements and promotes the expiratory ones.
One pad on the lumbar deformity: the support force of this pad is diametrically opposed to the thoracic one to facilitate spinal detorsion. If needed, this lumbar pad will render some lordosis by pressing on vertebrae transverse apophysis (Figure 2).
Thoracic scoliosis: the brace is equipped with only one pad on the dorsal deformity, associated with two counter-supports; one superior under-axillary counter-support on the opposite side to the thoracic curve and another inferior counter-support next to the lumbar column, still opposite to the thoracic curve.
The deformation 3D correction is made by adjusting precisely the location and the pressure of the pad, as explained before.
The pad will be all the more lateral that the torsion is important; in this case, it is no more directly on the hump noticed by clinical examination. The more anterior is the pad, the more necessary it is to put another mobile pad (and not only a simple rigid counter-support) to avoid the lumbar kyphosis.
Adaptation difficulties: the CMCR is sometimes difficult to adapt in high thoracic scoliosis, with a few place for the superior counter-support.
Thoraco-lumbar scoliosis: the brace is equipped with an only pad on the thoraco-lumbar deformity, associated with two rigid counter-supports. Be careful not to disturb the sagittal plane (as can be seen with the hyper corrective brace) as the main pad must allow a dual objective: regain some dorsal kyphosis and some lumbar lordosis. It is only by the 3D analysis that the pad correct orientation can be found and then proved when the brace adaptation is completed.
The CMCR is a monoshell brace with an innovative system of mobiles pads. It preserves vital capacity by mobile pressures in thoracic and in lumbar, thanks to use of prestressed carbon. It retains pads from the Lyon brace, but gives more opportunities to orient forces .
Three strengthening pieces of Kydex (KYDEX sheet is an acrylic-polyvinyl chloride composite produced by KYDEX, LLC. Engineered for thermoforming fabrication, KYDEX sheet, combines the advantageous properties of both the acrylic and the polyvinyl chloride components. From acrylic, it obtains superior rigidity and formability; from PVC, outstanding toughness, chemical resistance and good interior finish ratings) plasticstiffen this shell: one medial posterior that stiffens the sagittal plane and two lateral ones that set in addition the carbon blade.
It is independent of the main shell and provides lateral translation. The pressure of the pad is lateral and paravertebral (to correct lumbar rotation and to maintain lumbar lordosis).
The carbon blade is the link between the brace and the pad (slipped under the lateral reinforcement and fixed on it).
This attachment device allows variations of strength and/or location of the pad.
The carbon blade is the link between the brace and the pad; its suppleness allows rib cage movements for a good breathing. (It is slanted to follow the ribs inclination).
This attachment device allows variations of strength and/or location of the pad.
These blades are made of carbon fibre braids (mainly unidirectional).Their thickness, determined by the number of layers, gives the searched flexibility according to every type of patients.
The carbon blade is prestressed and keeps pressure during exhalation.
The main system of opening and closing is a flexible rack at chondro-costal awnings level to maintain a constant clamping. Velcros at manubrial and pelvis levels complete it.
Foam is added on pressure area and sub axillary. A leather flap is placed on the opening of the brace, between the two polyethylene parts.
The CMCR is prescribed after a clinical and radiological examination of the patient. The prescription takes into account patient age, scoliosis progression and deformity reducibility. Here is the standard prescription form for a combined scoliosis:
∘ Right dorsal pad T5-T12. Specify the orientation that should be given to the pad: ¾ posterior or lateral.
∘ Left lumbar pad T12-L4. Specify the orientation that should be given to the pad: postero-anterior or lateral.
∘ Rigid left sub-axillary counter-support.
∘ Control of the chondro-costal awnings, with kyphosis effect if necessary.
The sensor consists in a portico of 2 meters side square in the center of which the patient is placed. 4 CDD camera recorders are symmetrically distributed in 4 columns, as well as 8 structured light projectors that project alternatively black and white fringes on the patient. The deformation of these fringes allows the calculation of the bust outer surface.
The acquisition is completed within less than 2 seconds (which allows an optimal posture).
Its accuracy is of the order of one millimeter.
It is then placed at the center of the sensor, elbows apart and hands forward at shoulder height, on two vertical stands.
At this stage we realize the brace final form with expansion areas and pressure areas on deformities, as well as the creation of the waist that will be the brace base).
Thermoforming of polyethylene (PE) is made at 160° by manual draping on the foam positive. The welding of PE plate is made on the front part of the positive (since the opening of the brace is anterior). The PE cools all night long, and the brace is removed from the positive the next morning.
This molded trial brace is then put on the patient, as if it were the final brace (it should not be too big not to hurt the patient, and should allow to keep a precise vision of the definitive brace). It is maintained closed with tape.
Fitting helps to:
Control volumes adaptation
Define the cutting on different sides of the brace : anterior (chest), superior (clavicles), and inferior (in the groin)
Determine the location of the pads (with help of radiological and clinical examination)
Determine the place of carbon blades as well as the power that will be applied on pads (depending on the thickness and the width of the blade)
Determine where the Kydex® reinforcements should be placed
Precise the position of the expansion areas
We realize then 3 Kydex® reinforcements (a posterior one and 2 side ones), which are coupled to the brace by rivets.
Still checking radiography, the orthotist puts the brace on the child who wears a cotton seamless shirt.
He makes sure that the brace is well adapted, with all parts on the right height. The fitting depends on the scoliosis importance and reducibility. The child should not be too embarrassed by its brace, and especially the sitting position should be paid attention to.
Before starting treatment, the patient and its parents receive oral and written explanations on the kind of brace and on the different steps of its manufacture and adaptation.
To be enlightened before making the choice of treatment, the patient receives as well oral and written information about inconvenience that might occur during treatment (as for example cutaneous irritation, sleeping troubles, constriction feeling…) and means to prevent it.
CMCR-wearing patients and their parents benefit throughout treatment from a therapeutic education to be able to manage treatment by themselves.
The child is seen every morning during one week to adapt brace, adjust carbon pressure, and improve comfort and quality of life in orthosis.
A front/profile radiography is done at the late brace adaptation to control its effectiveness (especially to confirm that all supports are well-oriented and at the right height). This x-ray is compared to x-ray without brace as well as face x-ray with partial suspension [9, 10].
In the making and at the brace delivery, simple explanation is given to get the child and its parents understand how the brace works.
Fitting tips: indelible marks are put on brace straps to help along.
Tips to put on and off the brace without help, which is part of the therapeutic education: either in a standing position or in a lying one.
Cleaning tips: brace is worn on a seamless T-Shirt that should be changed every day. Brace has to be washed with soap once a week.
In case of technical problem: manufacturer and referent physiotherapist at Les Massues can be joined by phone. Address and telephone number of the fabricant workshops are given, depending on where the patient lives, to correct technical problems if necessary.
Three months after brace adaptation, the patient is first seen by the referent physiotherapist at Les Massues, who assesses how the brace is physically and psychologically tolerated, how respiratory capacity, height and weight evolve. The patient benefits then from a clinical examination by the senior physician doctor (codified clinical examination without brace) and meets afterward the orthotist. All this controls are carried out in a multidisciplinary united consultation at day hospital.
After 6 months of brace wearing, these controls are made again besides a face/profile naked standing radiography which is compared to the initial one.
Successive checking is made every 6 months with naked face radiography.
The brace renewal is proposed when growth no longer allows a correct adaptation of the orthosis (cutaneous or bone conflicts impossible to resolve). We cannot adapt the distance between pelvic girdle and sub-axillary supports which is an advantage of Lyon brace.
A synthetic form of clinical and radiological patient data (“spine sheet”) is regularly supplemented to have an insight into scoliosis evolution at a glance.
During pubertal growth period, brace is worn on average 20–21 hours out of 24, with permission to take it off for sport practice at school and outside school.
When the peak of pubertal growth has gone away (at least 18 months after the first menstrual period), and if the improvement is stabilized concerning weight and sitting height, a gradual removal is started…until a night wearing the last 6 months of treatment. At that time, sitting height, standing height and weight are stable since about one year.
Before the pubertal growth and if scoliosis is moderate and supple (less than 25°), brace will not be worn at school but will be worn around 18 hours from school end until the next morning.
Breathing work: getting aware of abdominal and diaphragmatic breathing, fight against restrictive syndrome
Trying to get more spinal mobility: asymmetric exercises to open concavity(ies) and ilio-lumbar angle (stretching), fight against the increase of sagittal deformities (erasing or accentuation of curves), active axial self-extension (symmetrical stretching and muscles developing in long position)
Harmonization of anterior and posterior muscles: spinal muscles developing in long position, abdominal strengthening (chondro-costal awnings, pelvic tilt, …)
Upkeep of sub-pelvic extensibility and musculature: upkeep of sub-pelvic muscles extensibility (growth), strengthening exercises to compensate for the lack of mobility caused by the orthosis
First sight of relaxation
Characteristics of the population at the beginning of treatment with CMCR brace and at its definitive removal
Group at the beginning of treatment
Group at the definitive brace removal
12 years 3 months
11 years 1 month
15 years 5 months
Theoretical Vital Capacity (VC)
Forced Vital Capacity (FVC)
At the definitive brace removal, all kinds of scoliosis are stabilized by the orthosis and VC has increased. One may infer that the patient presents at the end of treatment a low residual deformity, which is unlikely to keep on getting worse in adulthood.
Later in this work we compare the group treated with CMCR to a group of patients treated with Lyon brace .
Characteristics of the population at the beginning of treatment with Lyon brace
Kind of scoliosis
Lyon brace is used later that CMCR to treat scoliosis: 2 years later on average in girls and 3 years later on average in boys.
Characteristics of the population at the beginning of treatment with Lyon brace and at its definitive removal
Mean at the beginning of treatment
Mean at the definitive brace removal
13 years 3 months
15 years 7 months
14 years 7 months
Comparative study – Impact of the brace kind on evolution of FVC (forced vital capacity)
<0,05 = *
FVC evolution at the brace setting up (liters)
FVC evolution at brace definitive removal compared to the beginning of treatment (liters)
As shown by the table below, VC decreases less at the CMCR setting up (−0.3) than at the Lyon brace setting up (−0.5) and this difference is significant.
At definitive brace removal, VC has more increased in CMCR (0.4 liter on average) than in Lyon brace (0.3 liter on average) but this difference is not significant.
The Lyon brace setting up must be preceded by a reduction by Abbott plaster to reduce curve importance. Scoliosis treated by CMCR are generally less pronounced; however it can happen that in our daily practice we begin treatment with a scoliosis reduction cast, followed by a CMCR if the obtained correction is sufficient to be maintained by CMCR carbon supports.
The Lyon treatment can only be started around puberty whereas CMCR can be used whatever the age.
This leads us to propose several kinds of brace (CMCR, Milwaukee brace, Lyon brace, hyper-correcting brace) for our scoliotic patients to make a choice depending on patient age, importance of scoliosis…
It is not possible to treat all kinds of scoliosis with an only brace.
CMCR brace is innovative for several reasons:
The use of prestressed carbon corrects deformity without blocking chest movements and thus preserves respiratory capacity in brace.
The scoliosis correction is progressive through the use of mobile supports which can always be adapted to the stiffness areas appearing throughout growth.
Radiological analysis with 3D reconstruction is used before brace design and at the late adaptation to get an optimal scoliosis correction by using minimal support forces.
3D analysis of scoliosis is essential to allow a gradual return to a harmonious cervical, dorsal and lumbar profile.
It has been demonstrated that CMCR brace allows a better quality of life than Lyon brace [14, 15]. Orthopaedic treatment is still a heavy treatment for adolescents in growth period; this orthosis is designed to preserve partly spine and chest mobility.
We hope so to have part in improving life conditions of these teenagers, compared to those treated with rigid braces.
The patients who participated in this work and, in particular, the patients shown in the iconography gave their written agreement as well as their parents.
This study was approved by the Ethics Committee of the Massues’Center- Croix-Rouge française.
This article is published under license to BioMed Central Ltd. This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/2.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.