Lack of evidence of WNT3A as a candidate gene for congenital vertebral malformations

  • Nader Ghebranious1,

    Affiliated with

    • Cathleen L Raggio2,

      Affiliated with

      • Robert D Blank3, 4Email author,

        Affiliated with

        • Elizabeth McPherson5,

          Affiliated with

          • James K Burmester6,

            Affiliated with

            • Lynn Ivacic1,

              Affiliated with

              • Kristen Rasmussen5,

                Affiliated with

                • Jennifer Kislow1,

                  Affiliated with

                  • Ingrid Glurich7,

                    Affiliated with

                    • F Stig Jacobsen8,

                      Affiliated with

                      • Thomas Faciszewski8,

                        Affiliated with

                        • Richard M Pauli9,

                          Affiliated with

                          • Oheneba Boachie-Adjei10 and

                            Affiliated with

                            • Philip F Giampietro5Email author

                              Affiliated with


                              DOI: 10.1186/1748-7161-2-13

                              Received: 24 July 2007

                              Accepted: 23 September 2007

                              Published: 23 September 2007



                              Prior investigations have not identified a major locus for vertebral malformations, providing evidence that there is genetic heterogeneity for this condition. WNT3A has recently been identified as a negative regulator of Notch signaling and somitogenesis. Mice with mutations in Wnt3a develop caudal vertebral malformations. Because congenital vertebral malformations represent a sporadic occurrence, linkage approaches to identify genes associated with human vertebral development are not feasible. We hypothesized that WNT3A mutations might account for a subset of congenital vertebral malformations.


                              A pilot study was performed using a cohort of patients with congenital vertebral malformations spanning the entire vertebral column was characterized. DNA sequence analysis of the WNT3A gene in these 50 patients with congenital vertebral malformations was performed.


                              A female patient of African ancestry with congenital scoliosis and a T12-L1 hemivertebrae was found to be heterozygous for a missense variant resulting in the substitution of alanine by threonine at codon 134 in highly conserved exon 3 of the WNT3A gene. This variant was found at a very low prevalence (0.35%) in a control population of 443 anonymized subjects and 1.1% in an African population.


                              These data suggest that WNT3A does not contribute towards the development of congenital vertebral malformations. Factors such as phenotypic and genetic heterogeneity may underlie our inability to detect mutations in WNT3A in our patient sample.


                              Congenital vertebral malformations are phenotypically and etiologically heterogeneous. Their estimated incidence is between 0.5 to 1/1000 [14]. Vertebral malformations may represent an isolated finding, occur in association with other renal, cardiac, or spinal cord malformations, or occur as part of an underlying chromosome abnormality or syndrome. These include, but are not limited to, hemifacial microsomia, Alagille, Jarcho-Levin, Klippel-Feil, Goldenhar,, basal cell nevus, trisomy 18, diabetic embryopathy and VACTERL (vertebral, cardiac, renal, limb anomalies, anal atresia, tracheo-esophageal fistula) syndromes. Vertebral malformations most commonly include hemivertebrae, vertebral bars, supernumerary vertebrae, butterfly vertebrae, and wedge-shaped vertebrae.

                              Congenital scoliosis is caused by segmentation defects such as fused vertebrae, vertebral body formation defects, and mixed defects in which both types of lesions are encountered [3, 4]. Each of these conditions may cause development of a spinal curve based on asymmetric growth. The severity of the curve is related to the type of defect and whether or not the primary problem is accompanied by any compensatory developmental changes.

                              Vertebral segmentation proceeds through a clock and wave front mechanism under Notch signaling control. Negative feedback through the canonical Wnt/β catenin pathway via Axin 2 modulates the process [5, 6]. Based on mouse-human synteny analysis, a series of candidate genes known to cause vertebral malformations in the mouse have been identified [58]. One gene, Wnt3a, is necessary for generation of the posterior portion of the neuraxis, as knockout mice fail to develop a tailbud and are truncated from a point slightly anterior to the hindlimbs [9]. This gene is a member of a moderate-sized multigene family comprised of at least 12 members in humans and the mouse. Genes in this family function both in establishing the body plan in development and as potential oncogenes [10]. Wnt3a has been proposed to be a major controlling gene in the oscillation of Notch signaling that is necessary for segmentation to occur [5].

                              Since isolated congenital vertebral malformation most often represents a sporadic occurrence within a particular family, it is virtually impossible to utilize traditional linkage approaches to identify causative genes. This makes candidate gene analyses a viable alternative method to study this condition. We hypothesized that mutations in WNT3A may be associated with the development of isolated vertebral malformations and congenital scoliosis. In order to test this hypothesis we undertook a pilot study and performed DNA sequence analysis in a heterogeneous cohort of 50 patients with congenital vertebral malformations.


                              Vertebral malformation subjects

                              Fifty children and adults with radiographic evidence for congenital segmental vertebral malformations were identified from the orthopedics and clinical genetic practices at Marshfield Clinic, Marshfield, Wisconsin, the Pediatric Orthopedics Department at the Hospital for Special Surgery, New York, New York, and the Bone Dysplasia Clinic at the University of Wisconsin, Madison.

                              Medical records of each patient were reviewed to determine if cardiac, renal, or spinal cord malformations were previously identified. Blood samples or buccal swabs were obtained from index cases (probands) and parents (when available) for subsequent DNA analysis. Five tissue samples were obtained from stillborn infants through the Wisconsin Stillbirth Program. Subjects' vertebral malformations were classified as previously described [11].

                              Mutational Analysis

                              Genomic DNA was amplified and the products were purified using the QIAquick PCR purification kit (QIAGEN, Inc., Valencia, California) and sequenced using either unidirectional or bi-directional di-deoxy sequencing with the DYEnamic ET Terminator Cycle Sequencing Kit (Amersham Biosciences Corp., Piscataway, New Jersey) on the PRISM 3100 Genetic Analyzer (Applied Biosystems, Foster City, California). Sequence analysis was performed using DNASTAR software (DNASTAR, Madison, Wisconsin). The same primers were used for amplification and sequencing. Primers and product sizes are shown in Table 1.
                              Table 1

                              Primers and corresponding product sizes




                              Product size (bp)

































                              • WNTE3Mut(F)

                              ACGTTGGATG ACACGCTCATGTGCAGAAGG



                              • WNTE3Mut(R)

                              ACGTTGGATG TACAGCCACCCCACTTCCAG



                              • WNTE3Mut(UE)




                              • WNT-pr(F)

                              ACGTTGGATG TATCCGAGTGGGGCCATCGC



                              • WNT-pr(R)

                              ACGTTGGATG CGCCAGCTCCCAGGGCCCG



                              • WNT-pr(UE)




                              The amplification and extension primers used in the homogeneous mass extend reaction are bulleted. The 10-mer tag used that increases the mass of the amplification primers so that they would fall outside the mass spectrophotometer range of analysis are bolded. UE denotes the unextended primers used in the mass extend reaction.

                              DNA sequence variants identified in subjects with vertebral malformations were compared to the UCSC goldenPath May 2004 sequence assembly [12].

                              Allele frequencies were determined in the control population using the homogeneous mass extend reaction and the matrix-assisted laser desorption/ionization time-of-flight mass spectrophotometer (Sequenom) [13]. A panel of 443 subjects (360 of whom were from the CEPH diversity panel) was tested for the WNT3A variant. The panel consisted of 126 subjects from African ancestry, 299 were Caucasians, 12 were Oceanic, and 6 were Asians. A panel of 23 anonymized DNA samples was used to determine the frequency of the WNT3A C/G promoter polymorphism, respectively.


                              Vertebral malformations were classified as butterfly vertebra, segmentation defect, or hemivertebra/hypoplasia. The vertebral malformations spanned the length of the entire spine and were classified as butterfly vertebrae, segmentation defect, hypoplasia and hemivertebrae [4]. Butterfly vertebrae were defined by the presence of a sagittal cleft. Segmentation defects include defects arising from intervertebral discs such as block vertebrae and unsegmented vertebral bars. The vertebral malformations spanned the length of the entire spine and are illustrated (figure 1). The malformation characteristics of the study sample are highlighted in Table 2.
                              Figure 1

                              Relative occurrence of vertebral malformations by spinal level and type.

                              Table 2

                              Malformation characteristics of study sample (n = 50)

                              Category of diagnosis of vertebral malformation


                              Isolated vertebral malformation(s)


                              Multiple congenital anomalies


                              VACTERL syndrome


                              Klippel-Feil syndrome


                              Facio-auriculo-vertebral spectrum and Goldenhar


                              Jugulolymphatic obstruction sequence


                              Sacral agenesis


                              Spondylothoracic dysplasia


                              Spondylocostal dysostosis


                              To analyze the WNT3A gene in the selected vertebral malformation cohort, a total of four segments in the WNT3A gene were amplified and sequenced in each patient. The sequencing covered the four exonic regions, splice junctions, and 381 bp of the promoter region. A 23-month-old female child of Cape Verde African ancestry with an isolated T12-L1 hemivertebrae and congenital scoliosis with a 38° lumbar scoliotic curve was found to be heterozygous for a G CC to A CC missense variant at codon 134 (UCSC position chr1:224,545,178 May 2004 assembly) of the WNT3A gene (figure 2), resulting in the substitution of alanine by threonine. The patient's clinically asymptomatic father was also heterozygous for the missense variant, whereas her mother was not. This exon is highly conserved, whereas codon 134 is less conserved in this exon. Interestingly, the alanine amino acid at codon 134 is conserved in mouse, rat, dog and opossum, whereas in elephant, chicken, Xenopus tropicalis and tetradon, alanine is replaced by threonine. To check for the prevalence of this variant in reference population, a total of 890 chromosomes from 445 subjects were tested for the WNT3A mutation, of which 133 were of African origin, 299 were Caucasians, and 11 were Asians. Only three subjects of African origin (Yoruba, Mbuti, and Bantu N.E.) were heterozygous for the variant. The overall prevalence of the variant in the tested reference population is 0.35%.
                              Figure 2

                              Sequencing chromatogram of patient with T12-L1 hemivertebrae illustrating WNT3A exon 3 polymorphism.

                              Moreover, a novel C/G single nucleotide variant was also found in the promoter region of the WNT3A gene (UCSC position chr1:224,501,511 May 2004 assembly). The patient cohort had an average heterozygosity of 0.130 and allele frequencies of 0.93 and 0.07 for the C and G alleles, respectively. In order to determine the significance of this variant, we typed a panel of 23 anonymized reference DNA samples of Caucasian ancestry. The average heterozygosity for this variant in the reference cohort was calculated to be 0.159 and the allele frequencies were 0.91 and 0.09 for the C and G alleles, respectively. The genotype distribution for this variant did not differ significantly between the patient's and reference cohorts (Chi-squared = 0.001, p-value = 0.97) and were in Hardy-Weinberg equilibrium in both cohorts. We conclude that this variant likely represents a polymorphism.


                              In a series of 50 patients with a broad array of vertebral malformations encompassing the entire length of the spinal column, we only identified a non-synonymous variant in exon 3 of WNT3A, resulting in substitution of alanine for threonine. Our observation of this variant with an overall frequency of 0.35% in the control population studied, and a frequency of 1.1% of African chromosomes included in the control population suggest and the observation that the patient's clinically asymptomatic father harbors the same variant strongly suggest that this variant may represent a polymorphism in the African population. Based on the data obtained from our pilot study, mutations in the WNT3A gene do not appear to be a common etiologic factor in the development of congenital vertebral malformations.

                              Patient heterogeneity for vertebral malformations and heterogeneity of candidate genes represent major limitations in genetic analyses. It is possible that mutations in WNT3A would have been identified if we had sequenced a cohort of patients characterized by having caudal vertebral malformation phenotypes. Because congenital vertebral malformations represent a rare condition, collection of a phenotypically homogeneous sample is not practical and would require a greater amount of time. DNA sequence analysis was limited to the WNT3A promotor, exons, and intron-exon boundaries. Sequence variants in the introns that could potentially contribute to abnormal transcription would not have been detected. Copy number variations in WNT3A will not have been detected by this methodology. Other genes that regulate the expression of WNT3A have not been examined.

                              Evidence for genetically heterogeneous etiologies of vertebral malformations includes the identification of mutations in DLL3 in patients with spondylocostal dysostosis [14, 15] and mutations identified in JAG 1 in patients with Alagille syndrome [16]. Recently, a few DNA coding sequence alterations with uncertain clinical significance in PAX1 and DLL3 have been identified in a cohort of patients with phenotypically characterized vertebral malformations [1720]. Our inability to detect mutations in WNT3A, as well as other candidate genes studied, may reflect differences in the regulation of somitogenesis in humans as compared to mice. It is possible that mutations in WNT3A are lethal in humans. Although our pilot study included 5 stillbirth samples and no mutations in WNT3A were detected, a larger cohort of stillbirth samples with vertebral malformations would be needed to determine whether mutations in WNT3A are prevalent among stillbirths with congenital vertebral malformations. Tissue mosaicism for a specific mutation and/or epigenetic factors may have an influence in the development of vertebral malformations in humans. Vertebral malformations may have greater environmental components than genetic components to their origin. A relationship between abnormal distribution of the intersegmental arteries and vertebral malformations was observed in 4 of 11 human embryos and fetuses with congenital vertebral malformations, suggesting the possibility that abnormalities in vascularization during the resegmentation process may contribute towards the development of congenital vertebral malformations [21].

                              Clinical relevance in identifying mutations associated with the development of vertebral malformations and congenital scoliosis is to develop a molecular classification system that could provide prognostic information regarding the severity of progression of congenital scoliosis and the presence of associated birth defects to practitioners and families. Although congenital scoliosis and idiopathic scoliosis represent dichotomous processes, namely a failure to develop normal vertebral structures for the former and a failure to lose normal vertebral structures for the latter, there is evidence that similar genetic factors may play a role in both conditions [22]. Identification of gene mutations which are associated with the development of congenital scoliosis may also help improve our understanding of the pathogenesis of idiopathic scoliosis.

                              In summary, we have been unable to detect mutations in the WNT3A gene in a pilot study of 50 patients with vertebral malformations encompassing the entire spine. This study illustrates the problems posed by attempting to design studies aimed at identification of patterning genes contributing towards the development of vertebral malformations. Future studies aimed at investigating the etiology of congenital vertebral malformations should be aimed at the study of additional candidate genes in a more homogeneous patient population.



                              This work was supported by the Scoliosis Research Society, Beatrice and Samuel A. Seaver Foundation and Marshfield Clinic Research Foundation. We acknowledge the technical assistance of Linda Weis and Alice Stargardt in the preparation of this manuscript. We also acknowledge Dr. Bernard A. Rawlins of the Hospital for Special Surgery, New York for referral of the patient with the T12-L1 hemivertebrae described.

                              This paper is Madison Veterans Affairs Geriatric Research, Education, and Clinical Center (GRECC) manuscript 2006-005.

                              Authors’ Affiliations

                              Molecular Diagnostic Research Laboratory, Marshfield Clinic
                              Department of Pediatric Orthopedics, Hospital for Special Surgery
                              University of Wisconsin Medical School
                              Geriatrics Research, Education, and Clinical Center, William S. Middleton Veterans Administration Medical Center
                              Department of Medical Genetic Services, Marshfield Clinic
                              Center for Human Genetics, Marshfield Clinic Research Foundation
                              Office of Scientific Writing and Publications, Marshfield Clinic Research Foundation
                              Department of Orthopedic Spine Surgery, Marshfield Clinic
                              Clinical Genetic Center, University of Wisconsin-Madison
                              Adult and Pediatric Spine Surgery, Hospital for Special Surgery


                              1. Shands AR Jr, Eisberg HB: The incidence of scoliosis in the state of Delaware; a study of 50,000 minifilms of the chest made during a survey for tuberculosis. J Bone Joint Surg Am 1955, 37-A: 1243–1249.PubMed
                              2. Wynne-Davies R: Congenital vertebral anomalies: aetiology and relationship to spina bifida cystica. J Med Genet 1975, 12: 280–288.View ArticlePubMed
                              3. McMaster MJ, Ohtsuka K: The natural history of congenital scoliosis. A study of two hundred and fifty-one patients. J Bone Joint Surg Am 1982, 64: 1128–1147.PubMed
                              4. McMaster MJ, Singh H: Natural history of congenital kyphosis and kyphoscoliosis. A study of one hundred and twelve patients. J Bone Joint Surg Am 1999, 81: 1367–1383.PubMed
                              5. Aulehla A, Wehrle C, Brand-Saberi B, Kemler R, Gossler A, Kanzler B, Herrmann BG: Wnt3a plays a major role in the segmentation clock controlling somitogenesis. Dev Cell 2003, 4: 395–406.View ArticlePubMed
                              6. Hayward P, Brennan K, Sanders P, Balayo T, DasGupta R, Perrimon N, Martinez Arias A: Notch modulates Wnt signaling by associating with Armadillo/beta-catenin and regulating its transcriptional activity. Development 2005, 132: 1819–1830.View ArticlePubMed
                              7. Giampietro PF, Raggio CL, Blank RD: Synteny-defined candidate genes for congenital and idiopathic scoliosis. Am J Med Genet 1999, 83: 164–177.View ArticlePubMed
                              8. Giampietro PF, Blank RD, Raggio CL, Merchant S, Jacobsen FS, Faciszewski T, Shukla SK, Greenlee AR, Reynolds C, Schowalter DB: Congenital and idiopathic scoliosis: clinical and genetic aspects. Clin Med Res 2003, 1: 125–136.View ArticlePubMed
                              9. Gruneberg H: Genetical studies on the skeleton of the mouse. XVI. Tail-kinks. J Genet 1955, 53: 536–550.View Article
                              10. Nusse R, Varmus HE: Wnt genes. Cell 1992, 69: 1073–1087.View ArticlePubMed
                              11. Erol B, Tracy MR, Dormans JP, Zackai EH, Maisenbacher MK, O'Brien ML, Turnpenney PD, Kusumi K: Congenital scoliosis and vertebral malformations: characterization of segmental defects for genetic analysis. J Pediatr Orthop 2004, 24: 674–682.PubMed
                              12. Human (Homo sapiens) Genome Browser Gateway [http://​genome.​ucsc.​edu/​cgi-bin/​hgGateway]
                              13. Ghebranious N, Ivacic L, Mallum J, Dokken C: Detection of ApoE E2, E3 and E4 alleles using MALDI-TOF mass spectrometry and the homogeneous mass-extend technology. Nucleic Acids Res 2005, 33: e149.View ArticlePubMed
                              14. Turnpenny PD, Bulman MP, Frayling TM, Abu-Nasra TK, Garrett C, Hattersley AT, Ellard S: A gene for autosomal recessive spondylocostal dysostosis maps to 19q13.1-q13.3. Am J Hum Genet 1999, 65: 175–182.View ArticlePubMed
                              15. Turnpenny P, Whittock N, Duncan J, Dunwoodie S, Kusumi K, Ellard S: Novel mutations in DLL3 , a somitogenesis gene encoding a ligand for the Notch signalling pathway, cause a consistent pattern of abnormal vertebral segmentation in spondylocostal dysostosis. J Med Genet 2003, 40: 333–339.View ArticlePubMed
                              16. Li L, Krantz ID, Deng Y, Genin A, Banta AB, Collins CC, Qi M, Trask BJ, Kuo WL, Cochran J, Costa T, Pierpont ME, Rand EB, Piccoli DA, Hood L, Spinner NB: Alagille syndrome is caused by mutations in human Jagged 1, which encodes a ligand for Notch 1. Nat Genet 1997, 16: 243–251.View ArticlePubMed
                              17. Giampietro PF, Raggio CL, Reynolds CE, Shukla SK, McPherson E, Ghebranious N, Jacobsen FS, Kumar V, Faciszewski T, Pauli RM, Rasmussen K, Burmester JK, Zaleski C, Merchant S, David D, Weber JL, Glurich I, Blank RD: An analysis of PAX1 in the development of vertebral malformations. Clin Genet 2005, 68: 448–453.View ArticlePubMed
                              18. McGaughran JM, Oates A, Donnai D, Read AP, Tassabehji M: Mutations in PAX1 may be associated with Klippel-Feil syndrome. Eur J Hum Genet 2003, 11: 468–474.View ArticlePubMed
                              19. Maisenbacher MK, Han JS, O'brien ML, Tracy MR, Erol B, Schaffer AA, Dormans JP, Zackai EH, Kusumi K: Molecular analysis of congenital scoliosis: a candidate gene approach. Hum Genet 2005, 116: 416–419.View ArticlePubMed
                              20. Giampietro PF, Raggio CL, Reynolds C, Ghebranious N, Burmester JK, Glurich I, Rasmussen K, McPherson E, Pauli RM, Shukla SK, Merchant S, Jacobsen FS, Faciszewski T, Blank RD: DLL3 as a candidate gene for vertebral malformations. Am J Med Genet A 2006, 140: 2447–2453.PubMed
                              21. Tanaka T, Uhthoff HK: The pathogenesis of congenital vertebral malformations. A study based on observation made in 11 human embryos and fetuses. Acta Orthop Scand 1981, 52: 413–425.View ArticlePubMed
                              22. Purkiss SB, Driscoll B, Cole WG, Alman B: Idiopathic scoliosis in families of children with congenital scoliosis. Clin Orthop Relat Res 2002, 401: 27–31.View ArticlePubMed


                              © Ghebranious et al. 2007

                              This article is published under license to BioMed Central Ltd. This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (http://​creativecommons.​org/​licenses/​by/​2.​0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.